Dive into the sweet world of Nailpollies' Sundae Best collection, a delectable range of ice cream-inspired nail polishes. This review explores five unique shades, each capturing the essence of a beloved frozen treat. From strawberry pink crellies shimmering with gold to a refreshing mint green infused with cool silver, prepare for a sensory experience as we uncover the texture, application, and overall impact of each polish. We'll delve into the details of their formulas, highlighting both their strengths and any minor nuances.This collection boasts not only vibrant colors but also a high level of craftsmanship. Expect smooth application, beautiful finishes, and the added touch of Nailpollies' signature handmade caps. We'll analyze the performance of each shade, discussing coverage, shimmer intensity, and overall wearability. Discover whether these ice cream-inspired hues live up to the hype, and if they deserve a spot in your nail polish arsenal. Prepare to indulge your senses with this comprehensive review of Nailpollies' Sundae Best collection.
Pros And Cons
- Builds up great in two coats
- Pastel glitter mix in white crelly base
- May need three coats
- Holographic microflakes not easily visible on nail
- Similar formula to Mint for Each Other
- Silver shimmer gives icy feel
- Builds up beautifully in two coats
- Surprisingly sheer on first coat
- Cool silvery shimmer
- Shimmer and metallic micro flakes stand out
- Silver shimmer adds to minty feel
- Builds well in two coats
- Iridescent micro flakes less visible on nail than in bottle
- Beautiful formula
- Smooth and even coverage
- Builds up beautifully in two coats
- Slightly sheer
- Iridescent flakes not easily visible
Read more: 10 Must-Have China Glaze Nail Polish Shades
I Love You Unconditionally: Strawberry Cheesecake Delight
This polish boasts a delightful strawberry pink crelly base, shimmering with a gold graham cracker crust effect. The formula is incredibly smooth and provides even coverage in just two coats, though a hint of nail line might be visible. The gold and iridescent microflakes add a touch of sparkle, creating a sophisticated yet playful manicure.

While the berry red metallic microflakes also contribute to the overall look, the iridescent flakes were less prominent on the nail than anticipated. Despite this minor detail, the polish remains a beautiful and easy-to-apply option, making it a favorite from the collection.

Mint for Each Other: A Cool Mint Chocolate Chip
A refreshing mint green crelly base forms the foundation of this polish, infused with a cool silvery shimmer and flecks of gold, rose gold, and iridescent microflakes. The shimmer adds a minty coolness to the color, though the iridescent flakes are less visible on the nail than in the bottle.

The formula is smooth and builds beautifully, creating a captivating finish. While the silver shimmer stands out, the overall effect is more minty than chocolate chip, a pleasant surprise for those who may not be fans of the ice cream flavor.

Sunday Funday: Rainbow Sherbet Fun
This playful polish is a white crelly base packed with a pastel hex glitter mix in pink, orange, aqua, periwinkle, and white. The mix of sizes, with a few larger pieces, adds depth and visual interest. A subtle holographic microflake is present, though less noticeable on the nails.

The formula applies smoothly, building to a vibrant finish in two to three coats. Because of the glitter content, a peel-off base is recommended for easier removal. Despite the slightly less noticeable holographic element, it remains a cheerful and summery choice.

What a Softy: Cookies and Cream Coolness
A soft charcoal semi-pearlescent base with a silver shimmer and silver metallic microflakes, this polish offers a sophisticated take on the cookies and cream theme. Despite a surprising sheerness in the first coat, it builds up nicely to an opaque finish in two coats.

The silver shimmer imparts a cool, icy feel, aligning well with the ice cream inspiration. While not the reviewer's favorite color, the formula is easy to work with, offering a smooth and even application.

Comparisons and Final Thoughts
The Nailpollies Sundae Best collection offers a delightful array of ice cream-inspired shades with unique formulas and captivating handmade caps. While some iridescent flakes were less visible on the nails than in the bottles, the overall quality and ease of application remain high.

Each polish has its own distinct charm and personality, from the playful glitter of Sunday Funday to the sophisticated shimmer of What a Softy. The collection is a must-have for nail polish enthusiasts seeking unique and beautifully packaged products. While some shades have comparable colors in other brands, the handmade caps and overall artistry of Nailpollies sets them apart.