Dive into Painted Polish's captivating "Naughty or Nice" collection, a summer nail polish escape that defies expectations. Forget bright neons; this ocean-inspired palette plunges you into a world of deep blues, enchanting greens, and sandy beige hues. Imagine the shimmering depths of the sea, the playful spirit of mermaids, and a touch of pirate adventure – all captured in eight uniquely formulated shades. This isn't your typical summer collection; it's a sophisticated, nuanced exploration of coastal beauty.Each polish boasts impressive pigmentation and a smooth, easy application, thanks to a thoughtfully designed wide brush. From sandy beige glitters to deep blue jellies bursting with flakies, the "Naughty or Nice" collection offers a variety of textures and finishes, ensuring there's a perfect shade for every nail art enthusiast. Discover a collection that prioritizes quality, creativity, and a refreshing departure from summer's usual bright palette. Prepare to be hooked!
Pros And Cons
- Five-free formula (free of five potentially harmful ingredients)
- Cruelty-free
- Unique color story
- Wide variety of colors and finishes (creams, jellies, glitters, flakies)
- Amazing formulas, mostly opaque in one or two coats
- Beginner-friendly
- Interesting color combinations
- Beautiful contrast between base colors and glitters/flakes
Read more: 10 Must-Have China Glaze Nail Polish Shades
A Unique Summer Color Story
Painted Polish's 'Etsy Naughty or Nice' collection defies typical summer nail polish trends. Instead of bright neons, it offers a captivating ocean-inspired palette. Deep blues, greens, and a sandy beige create a unique color story reminiscent of beaches, mermaids, and perhaps even a touch of pirate flair. The color combinations are particularly intriguing and unexpected for a summer release.
This collection offers a refreshing change from the usual summer brights. The deeper tones are sophisticated and evocative of coastal landscapes, providing a more nuanced and mature aesthetic. It's a perfect choice for those who appreciate a less predictable approach to seasonal nail colors.
The collection's uniqueness stems from its unexpected color choices for a summer release. This departure from typical summer bright tones makes it stand out and offers a refreshing alternative for those seeking something different.
Detailed Swatches and Formula Review
The collection includes eight shades, each with a distinct personality and formula. 'Hands Off My Booty' is a sandy beige with multicolored hex glitters, resembling scattered treasure. 'Hooked on a Keeling' and 'Mass to the Bone' are two distinct white crelly polishes, one cool-toned and one warmer, both bursting with colorful glitters.

'No Honor Among Reefs' is a stunning slate blue crelly with red, copper, and black flakes; a surprising favorite due to its unique color contrast. 'Crack in a Cold One' is a deep blue jelly packed with micro glitters and pink flakes, offering depth and sparkle. 'License to Krill' is a deep navy blue jelly with red and multicolored flakies creating a stunning contrast.

'Fishful Thinking' and 'Kelp Wanted' are jelly flakie polishes. 'Fishful Thinking' is a teal jelly with densely packed cool-toned flakies, while 'Kelp Wanted' is an olive green base with varied sizes of green, blue, pink, and red flakes offering a unique swampy vibe.

Formula and Application
Across the board, the formulas are consistently impressive. Most shades are nearly opaque in one coat, requiring two for full coverage. The application is smooth and easy, even with the heavily glittered polishes. The wide, flat brush contributes to even application, making them beginner-friendly.

The depth and complexity of the colors are noteworthy. Despite the abundance of glitters and flakies, the polishes maintain a cohesive and visually appealing finish. This level of quality is remarkable, and speaks to the attention to detail in the brand's formulation.
The brushes are specifically designed to make application a breeze. The combination of a wide brush and rounded tip ensures smooth and even distribution of color and embellishments, enhancing the overall application experience.
Pricing, Availability, and Overall Impression
The 'Etsy Naughty or Nice' polishes are available in 13.2ml bottles and retail for $12 USD each. A 10% discount code is available. The brand is praised for its unique color stories, high-quality formulas, and attention to detail in creating varied options within similar styles.
Painted Polish consistently delivers superior formulas and unique color combinations. This collection highlights their knack for creating polishes with depth and visual interest. The brand's commitment to quality is evident in every aspect, from the formula to the packaging.
Considering the quality of the formula, the unique color story, and the brand's commitment to ethics, this collection is definitely worth exploring. The price point is reasonable, especially with the available discount code. It's an excellent choice for nail polish enthusiasts who appreciate high-quality products with a distinct personality.