Painted Polish Nail Polish Review: Booked for Love & I Love Mint Collections

Dive into the captivating world of Painted Polish with our comprehensive review of their "Booked for Love" and "I Love Mint" nail polish collections. These two stunning lines offer a diverse range of colors and finishes, from richly pigmented crelly formulas bursting with flakies to sheer, glitter-infused shades that add a touch of whimsy. Prepare to be amazed by unexpected color combinations and innovative textures, expertly crafted for a seamless and satisfying application. Whether you're a seasoned nail art enthusiast or just starting out, Painted Polish delivers exceptional quality and stunning results.We explore each shade individually, detailing its unique characteristics and highlighting its versatility. From the literary-inspired depths of "Booked for Love" with its dusty pinks and vibrant oranges, to the refreshing coolness of "I Love Mint" with its playful mint green base and diverse glitter additions, this review provides a complete overview of both collections. Discover why Painted Polish is a brand setting new standards in nail polish innovation, offering a blend of creativity and high-quality formula at an accessible price point.

Pros And Cons

Painted Polish Nail Polish
  • Five-free (free of five potentially harmful ingredients)
  • Cruelty-free
  • Most polishes are one-coaters
  • Good opacity
  • Unique and interesting color combinations
  • Wide flat brush with rounded tip for easy application
  • Self-leveling formula (for stamping polish)
  • Some shades (like Frosty Flirtation) require two coats for full coverage

Read more: 10 Must-Have China Glaze Nail Polish Shades

Booked for Love Collection: Part 1

The Booked for Love collection, part one, kicks off with five unique shades inspired by literature. 'Feel and Thorny' is a standout pinky-toned red crelly base brimming with black, gold, and silver flakies. Its opacity is incredible; one coat provides almost full coverage, with two coats creating a rich, vampy finish.

Swatch of Feel and Thorny nail polish
Swatch of Feel and Thorny nail polish

Next is 'Fury and Fantasy,' a minty green crelly with the same stunning flakie mix. It's slightly deeper and more saturated than the polishes in the I Love Mint collection, providing a lovely contrast.

Swatch of Fury and Fantasy nail polish
Swatch of Fury and Fantasy nail polish

Then, we have 'Ruinous Romance,' a medium-warm toned purple crelly base. The gold flakies particularly shine in this shade, adding a spring-like warmth. It's a beautifully saturated purple, avoiding that sometimes-dull muted look.

Swatch of Ruinous Romance nail polish
Swatch of Ruinous Romance nail polish

Booked for Love Collection: Part 1 Continued

'Frosty Flirtation' offers a light sky blue base, slightly sheerer than the others. Two coats are needed for full coverage, revealing a gorgeous contrast with the gold flakies against the bright blue. This shade is versatile for any season.

Swatch of Frosty Flirtation nail polish
Swatch of Frosty Flirtation nail polish

Finally in part one, 'Flames of Fancy' is a vibrant orange crelly. The silver flakies seem to blend with the orange, creating a unique, almost yellowish-gold effect. This shade gives a fun, tiger-like vibe.

Swatch of Flames of Fancy nail polish
Swatch of Flames of Fancy nail polish

Booked for Love Collection: Part 2

Part two of the Booked for Love collection begins with 'Lakeside Love,' a slightly dusty medium pink with purple, red, and gold flakies. It's a nostalgic, bubblegum-like shade unlike anything else.

Swatch of Lakeside Love nail polish
Swatch of Lakeside Love nail polish

'Stop in the Name of Love' is a dusty lavender purple with a unique mix of black, golden yellow, and red flakies. Painted Polish's knack for unexpected color combinations shines here.

Swatch of Stop in the Name of Love nail polish
Swatch of Stop in the Name of Love nail polish

'Royal Rendezvous' is a darker, dustier blue with intense red and light pink flakies. The striking color contrast makes it a versatile choice for any season.

Swatch of Royal Rendezvous nail polish
Swatch of Royal Rendezvous nail polish

Booked for Love Collection: Part 2 Continued

'Winging It' is a beige-mustardy yellow with black, gold, and silver flakies. While some may find it unusual, its unique, almost kitchen-countertop aesthetic is surprisingly appealing.

Swatch of Winging It nail polish
Swatch of Winging It nail polish

The final shade, 'Steamy Storm,' is a light gray with the same flakie mix. Unlike 'Winging It,' this one is simply pretty, resembling a stone or granite finish. The gold flakies add an interesting pop of color.

Swatch of Steamy Storm nail polish
Swatch of Steamy Storm nail polish

I Love Mint Collection

The I Love Mint collection features six polishes sharing a light mint green base but boasting diverse flakies and glitters. 'Mint Chip Magic' perfectly resembles mint chocolate chip ice cream with varying sizes of black flakies.

Swatch of Mint Chip Magic nail polish
Swatch of Mint Chip Magic nail polish

'Mint Mosaic' is a sheerer formula showcasing a rainbow of hex-shaped glitters. It's like a confetti party on your nails!

Swatch of Mint Mosaic nail polish
Swatch of Mint Mosaic nail polish

'Freshly Minted' stands out with its jelly base, intense green and silvery-white flakies, and holographic sparkle. It's unique, elegant, and reminds me of American money.

Swatch of Freshly Minted nail polish
Swatch of Freshly Minted nail polish

I Love Mint Collection Continued

'Minty Muse' combines a mint green base with gold and holographic fuchsia hex glitter, creating a surprisingly stunning contrast. The richness of the fuchsia against the green is truly unique.

Swatch of Minty Muse nail polish
Swatch of Minty Muse nail polish

'Mint to Be' features a mint green base and intense reddish-pink flakies. It gives a strawberry-like vibe, showcasing another unexpected yet captivating color combination.

Swatch of Mint to Be nail polish
Swatch of Mint to Be nail polish

'Stamped in Mint Green' is a stamping polish with excellent one-coat opacity and self-leveling properties. It's easy to apply and stamps vibrantly, even on darker shades.

Swatch of Stamped in Mint Green nail polish
Swatch of Stamped in Mint Green nail polish

Overall Thoughts and Conclusion

Painted Polish delivers impressive formulas with excellent opacity and beginner-friendly application. The crelly formula is exceptionally easy to work with, making it perfect for both beginners and experienced nail polish enthusiasts.

All polishes shown together
All polishes shown together

The unique color combinations and diverse finishes across both collections are captivating. While you don't *need* every shade, the collections provide a wonderful range to choose from based on your preferences.

Overall, both the Booked for Love and I Love Mint collections are highly recommended. The quality, creativity, and unique color stories make Painted Polish a standout brand worth exploring. The polishes retail for $12 USD each, and a 10% discount can be obtained using the code KELLY10.